Best VPN Comparison 2025: NordVPN vs Surfshark vs ProtonVPN

When it comes to online security, privacy, and performance, three VPN providers consistently stand out: NordVPN, Surfshark, and ProtonVPN. Each has unique strengths, but how do they compare head-to-head? This guide explores their features, pros, cons, and everything in between, so you can decide which VPN suits your needs best.

Security and Privacy

NordVPN NordVPN’s reputation for robust security is well-deserved. It uses advanced encryption (AES-256) and operates RAM-only servers, ensuring that no data is stored long-term. Its no-logs policy has been independently audited four times, offering users peace of mind. Other features include a kill switch to prevent data leaks, a bug bounty program for vulnerability detection, and a privacy-friendly jurisdiction (Panama).

Surfshark Surfshark also offers RAM-only servers, an audited no-logs policy, and a kill switch. However, its jurisdiction in the Netherlands, part of a data-sharing alliance, may raise concerns for privacy purists. Despite this, Surfshark’s commitment to user privacy remains strong, bolstered by a bug bounty program and a reliable suite of security features.

ProtonVPN ProtonVPN’s standout feature is its open-source apps, allowing anyone to inspect their source code for transparency. While it lacks RAM-only servers, it compensates with strong encryption, a no-logs policy, and a privacy-friendly base in Switzerland. ProtonVPN also includes a kill switch and secure core servers for added protection.

Winner: Tie. All three VPNs prioritize security and privacy, but ProtonVPN’s transparency and NordVPN’s comprehensive audits give them a slight edge.

User Experience and App Design

NordVPN NordVPN’s app is sleek, intuitive, and user-friendly, featuring an interactive map for easy server selection. It’s compatible with major operating systems, smart TVs, and gaming consoles, ensuring seamless usability across devices.

Surfshark Surfshark’s app is similarly clean and straightforward, with a list-based server interface and search functionality. Its standout feature is unlimited device connections, making it ideal for families or users with multiple devices.

ProtonVPN ProtonVPN’s app is more advanced, featuring detailed server information and customization options. However, its complexity might overwhelm less tech-savvy users. Despite this, its pinned items and profiles offer quick access to frequently used servers.

Winner: Surfshark. Its unlimited device connections and simplicity make it the most accessible choice.

Features

NordVPN

• Specialized Servers: Onion over VPN and double VPN for enhanced anonymity.
• Threat Protection: Blocks malware, ads, and trackers.
• Meshnet: Securely connects devices for file sharing and gaming.
• Split Tunneling: Customizes which apps use the VPN.

Surfshark

• CleanWeb 2.0: Blocks ads and malicious sites.
• Rotating IP: Enhances anonymity by changing your IP address without disconnection.
• Surfshark One: Includes antivirus and other cybersecurity tools.
• Bypasser: A highly customizable split tunneling feature.

ProtonVPN

• Secure Core Servers: Routes traffic through multiple servers for extra security.
• NetShield: Blocks ads and malware.
• Accelerator: Claims to boost speeds by 400%.
• Always-On: Reconnects to the VPN automatically if disconnected.

Winner: NordVPN. Its extensive features and usability make it the most well-rounded option.

Speed and Performance

Speed tests show NordVPN consistently outperforms its competitors, retaining the highest average speeds. Surfshark follows closely, with impressive speeds in the US, while ProtonVPN, despite its accelerator, lags slightly behind.

Winner: NordVPN. Its superior speed retention makes it the best choice for streaming and torrenting.

Streaming and Torrenting

NordVPN With optimized servers and P2P support, NordVPN excels in streaming and torrenting. It reliably unblocks a wide range of streaming platforms and offers features like SOCKS5 proxy for added security.

Surfshark Surfshark supports streaming and torrenting on all servers but lacks P2P-optimized options. Occasional IP blocks can be resolved by switching servers.

ProtonVPN ProtonVPN’s secure core servers and port forwarding enhance torrenting. However, its limited streaming servers and slower speeds make it less versatile for streaming.

Winner: NordVPN. Its optimized servers and reliable performance give it a clear advantage.

Pricing

• Surfshark: The most affordable, especially for long-term plans.
• ProtonVPN: Mid-range pricing with a free tier (limited functionality).
• NordVPN: The most expensive, but offers comprehensive features.

Winner: Surfshark. Its budget-friendly pricing makes it an attractive option.

Conclusion

• NordVPN: Best for speed, advanced features, and overall performance.
• Surfshark: Best for affordability and unlimited device connections.
• ProtonVPN: Best for transparency and privacy-focused users.

Each VPN has unique strengths, so your choice depends on your priorities. Use the links below for the latest deals and discounts. Whichever you choose, you’ll enjoy enhanced online security and privacy.